Table Of Contents
Imagine you’re visiting someone’s apartment or rental home and you slip and fall because of loose cables or clothes left on the ground, resulting in a serious injury. Can you get your medical bills and expenses paid for? Who pays for them?
The answer depends on who was responsible for the hazard and where exactly you fell, and it isn’t always covered by the tenant’s renters insurance. Below, we’ll walk through when renters insurance applies to a slip-and-fall injury, when it doesn’t, and what your options are.
What Is Renters Insurance, and What Does It Cover?
Renter’s insurance is coverage that many landlords and leasing companies require tenants to have. It generally covers personal property that is damaged or destroyed, loss of use of the rental space, and personal liability for injuries that occur there. Renters insurance is meant to protect the tenant rather than the landlord, with that protection extending to guests as well. If a guest is injured in a rental unit because of the tenant’s negligence, the tenant’s renters insurance will likely cover that guest’s medical expenses.
For example, if a tenant fails to clean up a liquid spill on the floor, or fails to warn a guest about a hazard they know about in the rental space, the tenant could be legally liable for any resulting injury. Renters insurance typically applies to the space the tenant controls, such as the inside of the apartment or the steps leading up to a rental home. It generally does not cover common areas shared by other tenants or residents.
What Do You Need to Prove to Hold Someone Liable?
To hold a tenant or landlord responsible for a slip-and-fall injury, an injured person generally needs to show that the property owner or tenant knew (or reasonably should have known) about the hazardous condition and failed to fix it or warn guests about it. Simply falling and getting hurt isn’t enough on its own; the injury has to be tied to someone else’s failure to address a danger they were responsible for.
Missouri is also a pure comparative fault state, which means an injured person can still recover compensation even if they were partly responsible for the fall. Their total recovery is simply reduced by their percentage of fault, rather than being barred altogether. This is an important factor in slip-and-fall cases in particular, since a common defense tactic is arguing the hazard was “open and obvious” and the injured person should have avoided it.
When Does Renters Insurance Not Apply to a Slip-and-Fall Injury?
There are a few common scenarios where a tenant’s renters insurance won’t cover the medical expenses and other costs of someone injured on the rental property.
When the hazardous condition or object was the landlord’s responsibility
Renters insurance won’t cover structural or maintenance issues that fall under a landlord’s responsibility to fix. If someone falls because of an uneven floor or a leaking pipe, that wouldn’t be covered under the tenant’s renters insurance, since the landlord is responsible for fixing those issues. Renters insurance covers liability the tenant creates, not the landlord. This type of claim typically shifts to the landlord’s own liability insurance instead.
When you fall and injure yourself
Renters insurance usually covers injuries to other people rather than the policyholder’s own injuries from slipping and falling. Depending on the insurance company and state, a renters policy could cover the tenant’s own injuries from a fall, but most policies only cover guests.
When the fall occurred in a common area outside the space the tenant controls
If someone slips and falls in an apartment hallway, lounge, staircase, or parking lot, the tenant likely won’t be responsible, since those areas are controlled by the landlord rather than the tenant. The space inside a rental unit is what a tenant controls and could be held liable for. With standalone rental homes, renters insurance will likely cover the property itself but not areas outside it, like the sidewalk.
As with landlord-responsibility scenarios, an injury in a common area would typically be pursued against the landlord or property management company’s liability coverage rather than the tenant’s renters insurance.
What Happens If Renters Insurance Doesn’t Cover the Injury?
If a renters insurance policy doesn’t apply because the hazard was the landlord’s responsibility, or the fall happened in a common area, that doesn’t mean the injured person is without options. In most cases, the claim simply shifts to a different source of coverage: the landlord or property management company’s own liability insurance. In some situations, it may also be possible to pursue a claim directly against the tenant personally, outside of their insurance policy.
It’s also worth knowing that renters insurance policies typically carry liability limits, often somewhere between $100,000 and $300,000. For a serious injury, medical bills and lost income can quickly exceed those limits, which means the available insurance may not fully cover what’s owed. When that happens, identifying every applicable policy and source of recovery becomes essential, which is where having an attorney review the details of the incident can make a difference.
Assistance with Your Slip-and-Fall Claim
Figuring out who’s actually responsible for a slip-and-fall injury isn’t always straightforward. Whether renters insurance applies can depend on where the fall happened, who controlled that space, and whether the hazard was something the tenant should have fixed or something that was really the landlord’s responsibility all along.
At Cantor Injury Law, our attorneys know how to investigate and win slip-and-fall cases. We will identify every party and every policy that could be responsible, and make sure you’re not left covering costs that someone else should be paying. You don’t have to figure out the insurance and liability questions on your own. Call 314-628-9999 or reach out online for a free consultation, and let us help you understand your options and pursue the compensation you deserve.
